| Platinum | Pizza By Design |
| Gold | Brick Oven Pizza Co of Abilene |
| Gold | Joe's Pizza and Pasta |
| Silver | Vagabond Pizza |
| Bronze | Joes Pizza Buffalo Gap Rd |
| Bronze | Rockin' Woodfired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Cicis |
| Top Pick | Fazoli's |
| Top Pick | Little Italy |
| Top Pick | Potter's Pizza |