| Platinum | La Villa |
| Gold | Saint Vincent Depaul Thrift Store |
| Silver | Callahan Thrift |
| Bronze | Thrifty Treasures |
| Top Pick | Blue Willow Estate Sales and Consignments |
| Top Pick | Easy Pickin's Clyde |
| Top Pick | Frontier Flea Market |
| Top Pick | Lala's Consignments |
| Top Pick | Restore |
| Top Pick | The Crossing Indoor Flea Market |