| Platinum | Little Italy |
| Gold | Joe's Pizza and Pasta |
| Gold | Vagabond Pizza |
| Silver | Fazoli's |
| Bronze | La Stazione Fine Dining |
| Top Pick | Black Box Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dante's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Niko's Greek Gyros |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Texas Flaming Grill |